- Students will trace and evaluate efforts to achieve equality and protect the natural rights of blacks during the period following the Civil War.
- Students will analyze primary source documents and respond to a document-based question concerning efforts to achieve racial equality.
- Students will apply critical thinking skills to compare and evaluate proposals aimed at protection of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness for blacks in America.
- Students will participate in informed civil discourse aimed at solving problems related to controversial issues.
- Students will analyze documents and events to understand constitutional principles and essential virtues necessary for civil society.
- Handout A: Background Essay: African Americans in the Gilded Age
- Handout B: Ida B. Wells, “Lynch Law” 1893 (Excerpts)
- Handout C: Booker T. Washington: “The Atlanta Exposition Address” 1895 (Excerpts)
- Handout D: John Hope “We Are Struggling for Equality” 1896 (Excerpts)
- Handout E: John Marshall Harlan, Dissent from Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) (Excerpts)
- Handout F: W.E.B. DuBois, “The Talented Tenth,” 1903 (Excerpts)
- Handout G: W.E.B. DuBois: “Advice to a Black Schoolgirl” 1905
- Handout H: Niagara Movement Declaration of Principles 1905 (Excerpts)
- Handout I: Woodrow Wilson and the Negro Question, 1912 & 1914
- Handout J: Walter White, “The Eruption of Tulsa,” Nation, June 29, 1921 (Excerpts)
- Handout K: Constitutional Principles and Essential Virtues
- Handout L: Documents Organizer
- Thirteenth Amendment
- Fourteenth Amendment
- Fifteenth Amendment
- Freedmen’s Bureau
- Civil Rights Act, 1875
- Poll tax
- Literacy test
- Grandfather clauses
- Civil Rights Cases (1883)
- Jim Crow
- Plessy v. Ferguson (1896)
- Progressive Era
- Social Darwinism
- Tuskeegee Institute
- Up from Slavery
- Atlanta Exposition, 1895
- Souls of Black Folk
- Niagara Movement
- National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP)
- Spanish-American War
- World War I
- Great Migration
- Harlem Renaissance
- Civil Rights Movement
- Distribute and assign for homework the background essay, Handout A: African Americans in the Gilded Age.
- In class, lead a brief discussion to clarify any misunderstandings and have students share their responses to the review questions.
- Point out Handout K: Constitutional Principles and Essential Virtues. Review questions found throughout the lesson call for students to analyze documents regarding principles and virtues; this graphic organizer will be a useful tool for these discussions.
- Write the Key Question on the board so that students may refer to it throughout the lesson:
Which, if any, of the varying approaches advocated by black leaders during the period from 1865-1920 do you believe was the most likely to achieve equality and lead to protection of the rights of blacks? To what extent and in what ways did conditions for American blacks change in the era?
- Divide the class into three Study Groups of equal size. Though the number of documents varies, the number of pages assigned to each group is similar. Tell each group to fill in the parts of Handout L: Documents Organizer that coincide with their assigned documents, and that each student will become an expert, responsible for explaining their assigned documents to classmates. The teacher should monitor and move from group to group, helping where needed.
- Assign Study Group 1 to read and discuss the two documents related to racial violence: Handout B: Ida B. Wells, “Lynch Law,” 1893 and Handout J: Walter White, “The Eruption of Tulsa,” Nation, June 29, 1921.
- Assign Study Group 2 to read and discuss the three documents related to education policy: Handout C: Booker T. Washington: The Atlanta Exposition Address, 1895; Handout F: W.E.B. DuBois, The Talented Tenth, 1903, and Handout G: W.E.B. DuBois: Advice to a Black Schoolgirl, 1905.
- Assign Study Group 3 to read and discuss the four documents related to political, economic, and social equality: Handout D: John Hope “We Are Struggling for Equality” 1896; Handout E: John Marshall Harlan, Dissent from Plessy v. Ferguson (1896); Handout H: Niagara Movement Declaration of Principles 1905; and Handout I: Woodrow Wilson and the Negro Question, 1912 & 1914.
- Jigsaw to new teaching groups so that six students (two from each of the Study groups) are in each of the new groups. Their task in this phase is to share and discuss what they have learned about each document so that all students grasp the bigger picture and can fill in the remainder of the Handout K: Documents Organizer. Stress that students are to focus on synthesis and analysis of the documents as a whole, not just to fill in the rows on their documents organizer.
- Once all groups have finished the discussion of all documents and completed the documents organizer, then direct them to remain in their Teaching groups to discuss the Key Question.
- Conduct a whole-class discussion allowing each of the Teaching groups to share their answers to the Key Question.
- Ask: What was the proper role and responsibility of government in protecting the rights of blacks during this era? What mistakes and shortcomings can be instructive to us today? What virtues and constitutional principles are most relevant to achievement of civil society in which all persons can enjoy life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness?
- Have students write an essay in which they use the documents and their background knowledge to answer the Key Question. The writing could be done by individuals, or by groups of students working in teams. Have students exchange papers and apply the class grading rubric to one another’s essays.
- Have students collect and share current event articles that are related to the themes, principles, and virtues explored in this lesson.
- Have students write position papers as though they are advisors to elected officials today, using what they have learned from this lesson to recommend wise policy to address current events concerns.
- To what extent is the John Hope quote relevant in the 21st century?
“Rise, Brothers! Come, let us possess this land. Never say, ‘Let well enough alone.’ Cease to console yourselves with adages that numb the moral sense. Be discontented. Be dissatisfied. ‘Sweat and grunt’ under present conditions. Be as restless as the tempestuous billows on the boundless sea. Let your discontent break mountain-high against the wall of prejudice, and swamp it to the very foundation. Then we shall not have to plead for justice nor on bended knee crave mercy; for we shall be men. Then and not until then will liberty in its highest sense be the boast of our Republic…”
–John Hope, “We are Struggling for Equality,” 1896
Women in the Gilded Age and Progressive Era
African Americans in the Gilded Age | BRI’s Homework Help Series
The first in our new Institute of History Series of Homework Help videos provides a general overview of the experience of African Americans during the pivotal years of the Gilded Age, from the 1860s to the early 1900s. Despite the passage of the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments to the Constitution after the Civil War, which abolished slavery and granted citizenship and voting rights to African American men, millions of African Americans across the nation still faced an uphill struggle for equality and civil rights. Political disenfranchisement was widespread and segregation in the form of "Jim Crow" laws affected nearly every facet of public and private life in the South. Many African Americans migrated from the South to the North and West during this period. This era also saw the rise of dozens of notable African American civil rights leaders including Ida B. Wells, Frederick Douglass, Booker T. Washington, and W.E.B. Du Bois. Groups like the N.A.AC.P. were also established during this period to fight for the expansion of liberty and equality for African Americans.
Justice for All
By examining primary source documents, students will analyze the Founders’ concept of justice, liberty, and rights; where those concepts came from; and how they have changed over time.
To Accomplish the Most Good: Booker T. Washington’s Education
In this lesson, students will read about and discuss how Booker T. Washington remained diligent about obtaining an education. They will draft an illustrated “map” of Booker T. Washington’s journey toward an education, and they will discuss how they can be diligent in their own lives.
Debating Strategies for Change: Booker T. Washington vs. W.E.B. Du Bois
Use this Lesson with the Booker T. Washington, "Speech to the Cotton States and International Exposition," 1895 Primary Source to allow students to analyze and compare arguments for the early African American civil rights movement.